Blue Buffalo Reviews

Blue Buffalo has an overall rating of 4.6 based on 21 reviews. Customer feedback on Blue Buffalo is mixed: Blue Buffalo reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality ingredients, variety of flavors, positive impact on pet health, excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to pet owners seeking premium pet food options. However, Blue Buffalo is often criticized for its higher price point, occasional shipping issues, limited availability in some areas, some pets may not like certain flavors.

4.6/5.0

21 reviews

5 Stars

9

4 Stars

9

3 Stars

0

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Blue Buffalo Reviews (21)
JackBrunson
May 19, 2026
"Usually Find What I’m Looking For"
I usually have good luck finding what I need here. From the way the shelves look most of the time, I get the sense they stay on top of stocking things, since items are mostly available when I stop by.
Hedy_crabtree02
May 18, 2026
"Finally found something my picky dog actually wants"
My dog is ridiculously picky, but he actually eats this without giving me that judgmental stare first. I can’t prove it, but I feel like there’s something about the smell or texture that makes him way more interested than usual. Either way, he finishes the bowl, so I’m happy.
davekim4441
April 26, 2026
"I noticed my dog’s coat looking..."
I noticed my dog’s coat looking a little better after using this, and umm, he seems to be scratching less too. Not a huge dramatic change, but definitely some improvement with his skin and itchiness
TOOLE
April 12, 2026
"Switched to this no runs since. My dog..."
Switched to this no runs since. My dog seems to be doing good on it, so I’m happy.
BradleyMudget_84
April 12, 2026
"A brand I feel good about"
I’ve been buying Blue Buffalo for my dog for a while now, and overall I feel comfortable with it. The ingredients are easy enough to understand, and my dog has been doing well on it with no weird stomach issues or anything like that.
It is a little on the pricey side, and I do wish the info on the bags was simpler to compare sometimes. Still, I’d probably keep buying it and would gently recommend it if you’re looking for a dog food brand that feels dependable.
brandon_Notice99
March 29, 2026
"I found my dog’s food really quickly..."
I found my dog’s food really quickly, which was great, and the pages loaded without any weird delays. Checkout was simple enough too, not one of those confusing ones where you feel like you missed a step. The popups were a little annoying, if I’m being picky, but overall the site worked efficiently and I had a smooth experience. So yeah, mostly easy and kind of pleasantly uneventful.
William_lopez77
February 27, 2026
"Finally some relief for my itchy pup"
My dog was scratching like crazy and it had me feeling helpless. I was worried, then frustrated, and then so relieved when I started noticing he was much less itchy. He seems way more comfortable now, which makes me really happy.
james.Jacoby
February 19, 2026
"My dog’s into it, so I’m happy"
I’ve been happy with this Blue Buffalo food so far. The ingredients actually look like real food, which I appreciate, because I’m always kind of scanning the bag like okay, what am I feeding him here? My dog eats it without any fuss, like genuinely seems excited for mealtime, and I think his coat looks a little better too? Softer maybe, shinier, something like that. Anyway, no complaints from either of us.
Kimberli-niles
February 18, 2026
"Way Faster Than I Expected"
I had a quick question about my order and they got back to me fast. compared to a few other places I’ve ordered from, this was way easier, super helpful and no hassle at all
hello_william441
January 23, 2026
"Good food, just not the cheapest"
My dog seems to really like Blue Buffalo, and from what I can tell, the quality is solid. I don’t remember every brand I’ve tried, but this is one I keep coming back to. It is a little pricier than some others, though I feel better about buying it when I can grab it on sale.
Joe-morales
January 19, 2026
"Feels like a better everyday choice for my dog"
I switched over to Blue Buffalo because I wanted to feel more intentional about what I was feeding my dog, not just grab the cheapest bag and call it good. The ingredients seem a lot better than what I used before, and I like seeing meat listed first instead of a bunch of fillers I don’t really recognize. My dog seems satisfied after meals and has steady energy throughout the day, which makes me feel like the change was worth it. It does cost a little more, but feeding him something I feel good about every day gives me peace of mind.
JamesEason_07
January 14, 2026
"I liked that the ingredient info..."
I liked that the ingredient info was easy to find, because that’s usually the first thing I look for and I don’t want to dig around forever. Everything was clear enough, straightforward, and I could quickly tell what I needed to know without overthinking it...
FARMER
January 12, 2026
"My Blue Buffalo order actually showed..."
My Blue Buffalo order actually showed up in great shape, which shouldn’t feel like a big deal, but here we are. The bag wasn’t ripped, dented, or weirdly crushed, and the box was sturdy enough that nothing got smashed in transit. Pet food bags can turn into a total mess so fast if they split open, so I really appreciated that everything was clean, sealed, and not covered in kibble dust. Simple thing, but it makes a difference
richard_Spagnuolo82
January 02, 2026
"Feel good about the safety info"
I’m cautious about pet food, so I always look up recalls before buying anything. With Blue Buffalo, I’ve found the safety and recall info easy to track down, which gives me some peace of mind.

I know they’ve had recalls before, like a lot of bigger brands, but I appreciate that the information doesn’t feel buried or confusing. Has anyone else had the same issue with other brands where it’s weirdly hard to find clear recall details?

So far my dog has done well on their food, and I haven’t had any safety concerns personally. It just feels like they take that side of things seriously, which matters a lot to me...
OLIVER
January 02, 2026
"Got here quick"
Not a whole lot to explain, honestly. It showed up on time, maybe even a little faster than I figured. Delivery was smooth enough and there weren’t any issues...
AUSTIN
December 31, 2025
"Return felt fair overall"
I had to return a bag because my dog just didn’t seem to do well on it. i had a feeling quickly that it wasn’t the right fit for him. The return process started off a little slow, but once support got back to me, they handled it without making it feel like a big ordeal. My refund took a few days to show up on my card, which was kind of expected. Not a perfect experience, but my gut says they handled it fairly.
Tina.hardesty
December 20, 2025
"Good food, though I wish it stayed more consistent"
My dog usually does really well with Blue Buffalo, so I keep buying it because I figure if he’s happy and eating it, there’s no reason to switch just to switch. That said, I have noticed the kibble size and even the smell can be a little different from one bag to the next. He still eats it without a problem, so maybe I’m being picky, but I do wish it felt a bit more consistent. Overall, I’m still happy with it.
artie2001
December 06, 2025
"My dog’s stomach is doing better"
A friend actually recommended this food to me, so I decided to slowly switch my older dog over to it. His stomach seems a lot better now, and I’ve noticed his coat looks nicer too. Shipping was a little slow, but overall the food has worked really well for us.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Blue Buffalo?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.